Radioactive carbon dating problems

Argon/argon dating works using only the ratio of the concentration of the argon isotopes. For the purposes of this debate, "accurate" means that 95% of the dating errors are within 10% of the measured date, within the time span for which the isotope pair is utilized.Since carbon dating depends upon variable cosmic ray intensity, a calibration curve is assumed to be applied to account for that.other isotope pairs cover intermediate time periods between the spans for carbon 14 and uranium.

By analogy, a stop watch will not keep accurate time if it is not wound, if it is not in good repair, or if the operator forgets to press the button.

C14 is continually being created and decaying, leading to an equilibrium state in the atmosphere.

When the carbon dioxide, containing C14 as well as stable C12 and C13, is taken in by plants it is no longer exposed to the intense cosmic ray bombardment in the upper atmosphere, so the carbon 14 isotope decays without being replenished.

For example, the C14 concentration in the atmosphere depends upon cosmic ray intensity.

To take this into account, a calibration curve is developed using other dating methods to establish the C14 levels over time.

Leave a Reply